The 36 players chosen to participate in the first All-Star Game were at Comiskey Park, in uniform and ready to play that day in 1933. However, in most years since, one or more players was forced, or in some cases chose, to miss the game. Following is a complete list of those replacements. (Bold print indicates elected starter.) The list was created by Lyle Spatz, David Smith and David Vincent for the book The Midsummer Classic: The Complete History of Baseball's All-Star Game.
Please send any additions, such as telling us about an "Unknown", or corrections to the webmaster at retro2 --ATsign-- pankin.com
Year Team Replacement Replaced
1933 None
1934 NL OF Kiki Cuyler CHN OF Jo-Jo Moore NY
1935 AL OF Doc Cramer PHA OF Earl Averill CLE
NL P Bill Walker SLN P Van Mungo BRO
1936 AL P Vern Kennedy CHA P Tommy Bridges DET
1937 AL P Johnny Murphy NYA P Monty Stratton CHA
AL OF Sam West SLA OF Gee Walker DET
1938 AL P Johnny Murphy NYA 1B Hank Greenberg DET
NL C Harry Danning NY C Babe Phelps BRO
1939 NL SS Eddie Miller BSN 3B Cookie Lavagetto BRO
1940 AL 3B Cecil Travis WAS 3B Red Rolfe NYA
NL SS Eddie Miller BSN SS Billy Jurges NY
NL OF Bill Nicholson CHN OF Hank Leiber CHN
1941 NL 1B Frank McCormick CIN 1B Dolph Camilli BRO
NL OF Joe Medwick BRO OF Hank Leiber CHN
1942 AL C Hal Wagner BOS C Bill Dickey NYA
NL P Ray Starr CIN P Paul Derringer CIN
1943 AL OF Dick Wakefield DET OF Charlie Keller NYA
NL 1B Elbie Fletcher PIT 1B Frank McCormick CIN
NL P Ace Adams NY P Howie Pollett SLN
1944 AL OF Pete Fox BOS OF George Case WAS
NL SS Frankie Zak PIT SS Eddie Miller CIN
NL P Jim Tobin BSN P Red Munger SLN
NL P Bill Voiselle NY P Max Lanier SLN
1945 No game played
1946 NL 1B Frank McCormick PHI SS Pee Wee Reese BRO
NL 2B Emil Verban PHI SS Eddie Miller CIN
1947 AL P Early Wynn WAS P Bob Feller CLE
AL OF Tommy Henrich NYA OF Charlie Keller NYA
NL SS Pee Wee Reese BRO SS Eddie Miller CIN
NL 3B Whitey Kurowski SLN 3B Bob Elliott BOS
1948 AL P Joe Dobson BOS P Bob Feller CLE
NL 2B Bill Rigney NY 2B Eddie Stanky BSN
NL SS Buddy Kerr NY SS Marty Marion SLN
1949 None
1950 None
1951 None
1952 AL 3B Gil McDougald NYA 3B George Kell BOS
NL P Jim Hearn NY P Preacher Roe BRO
1953 NL C Clyde McCullough CHN C Del Crandall MLN
NL C Wes Westrum NY C Del Rice SLN
1954 AL P Dean Stone WAS 1B Ferris Fain CHA
AL 1B Mickey Vernon WAS 3B George Kell CHA
AL P Sandy Consuegra CHA P Mike Garcia CLE
AL OF Irv Noren NYA P Allie Reynolds NYA
NL P Jim Wilson MLN P Harvey Haddix SLN
1955 NL C Stan Lopata PHI C Roy Campanella BRO
1956 AL P Herb Score CLE P Ray Narleski CLE
NL C Stan Lopata PHI C Del Crandall MLN
1957 None
1958 None
1959-1 NL P Don Elston CHN P Wilmer Mizell SLN
1959-2 NL P Pedro Ramos WAS P Camillo Pascual WAS
1960-1 AL OF Jim Lemon WAS P Camillo Pascual WAS
1960-2 None
1961-1 None
1961-2 None
1962-1 AL P Milt Pappas BAL P Hoyt Wilhelm BAL
NL P Warren Spahn MLN OF Hank Aaron MLN
1962-2 AL P Ray Herbert CHA P Ken McBride LAA
1963 AL P Bill Monbouquette BOS P Steve Barber BAL
NL 2B Julian Javier SLN 2B Bill Mazeroski PIT
1964 AL SS Eddie Bressoud BOS SS Luis Aparicio BAL
AL OF Rocky Colavito KC OF Al Kaline DET
1965 AL C Bill Freehan DET OF Carl Yastrzemski BOS
AL 1B Joe Pepitone NYA 1B Bill Skowron CHA
AL OF Tony Oliva MIN OF Mickey Mantle NYA
1966 AL P Sonny Siebert CLE P Sam McDowell CLE
NL P Phil Regan LAN P Bob Gibson SLN
NL 2B Jim Lefevbre LAN 2B Joe Morgan HOU
1967 AL OF Ken Berry CHA OF Frank Robinson BAL
AL OF Tony Oliva MIN OF Al Kaline DET
NL P Chris Short PHI P Denny Lemaster ATL
1968 AL P Gary Bell BOS P Jose Santiago BOS
NL OF Billy Williams CHN OF Pete Rose CIN
NL SS Leo Cardenas CIN SS Gene Alley PIT
1969 AL 2B Mike Andrews BOS 2B Dave Johnson BAL
AL OF Roy White NYA OF Tony Oliva MIN
AL 1B Don Mincher SEA OF Mike Hegan SEA
1970 AL 2B Dave Johnson BAL 2B Rod Carew MIN
NL 2B Joe Morgan HOU 2B Felix Millan ATL
1971 AL C Dave Duncan OAK C Ray Fosse CLE
AL 1B Norm Cash DET 1B Boog Powell BAL
AL P Wilbur Wood CHA P Sam McDowell CLE
AL OF Reggie Jackson OAK OF Tony Oliva MIN
NL P Don Wilson CIN P Larry Dierker HOU
1972 AL SS Toby Harrah TEX SS Luis Aparicio BOS
AL SS Bobby Grich BAL SS Toby Harrah TEX
AL SS Bert Campaneris OAK SS Freddie Patek KCA
AL P Ken Holtzman OAK P Joe Coleman DET
NL P Ferguson Jenkins CHN P Gary Nolan CIN
1973 AL 1B Jim Spencer TEX 1B Carl Yastrzemski BOS
AL OF Pat Kelly CHA 1B Dick Allen CHA
NL SS Bill Russell LAN SS Dave Concepcion CIN
1974 AL C Ed Hermann CHA C Carlton Fisk BOS
AL C Jim Sundberg TEX C Ed Hermann CHA
AL 3B Don Money MIL 3B Sal Bando OAK
1975 AL SS Toby Harrah TEX 2B Jorge Orta CHA
1976 AL 2B Phil Garner OAK 2B Willie Randolph NYA
1977 AL P Nolan Ryan CAL P Frank Tanana CAL
AL P Dennis Eckersley CLE P Nolan Ryan CAL
AL P Jim Kern CLE P Mark Fidrych DET
AL P Jim Slaton MIL 2B Don Money MIL
AL 3B Wayne Gross OAK P Vida Blue OAK
NL P Rich Gossage PIT P Bruce Sutter CHN
1978 AL 2B Jerry Remy BOS SS Rick Burleson BOS
AL OF Dwight Evans BOS OF Carl Yastrzemski BOS
AL 3B Graig Nettles NYA OF Reggie Jackson NYA
AL OF Larry Hisle MIL 3B Graig Nettles NYA
AL C Darrell Porter KCA C Thurman Munson NYA
NL C Biff Pocoroba Atl C Johnny Bench CIN
1979 AL 1B Cecil Cooper MIL 1B Rod Carew CAL
NL 1B Keith Hernandez SLN OF Dave Kingman CHN
NL 3B Larry Parrish MON SS Dave Concepcion CIN
NL C Johnny Bench CIN C Ted Simmons SLN
NL C John Stearns NYN C Johnny Bench CIN
NL SS Craig Reynolds HOU SS Gary Templeton SLN
1980 AL OF Al Bumbry BAL OF Jim Rice BOS
AL 3B Graig Nettles NYA 3B George Brett KCA
AL 2B Bobby Grich CAL 2B Paul Molitor MIL
NL 3B Ray Knight CIN 3B Mike Schmidt PHI
NL P Ed Whitson SFN P Vida Blue SFN
1981 AL P Ron Davis NYA P Rich Gossage NYA
1982 AL 1B Andre Thornton CLE 1B Rod Carew CAL
1983 AL OF Ben Oglivie MIL OF Reggie Jackson CAL
AL P Tippy Martinez BAL P Ron Guidry NYA
1984 AL SS Alfredo Griffin TOR SS Alan Trammell DET
NL P Fernando Valenzuela LAN P Joaquin Andujar SLN
1985 AL C Rich Gedman BOS C Lance Parrish DET
NL OF Glenn Wilson PHI OF Pedro Guerrero LAN
NL C Terry Kennedy SDN C Gary Carter NYN
NL P Ron Darling NYN P Joaquin Andujar SLN
1986 AL 3B Brook Jacoby CLE 3B George Brett KCA
1987 AL 2B Harold Reynolds SEA 2B Lou Whitaker DET
AL 3B Kevin Seitzer KCA 3B George Brett KCA
1988 AL SS Kurt Stillwell KC SS Ozzie Guillen CHA
AL SS Cal Ripken, Jr. SS Alan Trammell DET
NL P Bob Walk PIT 2B Robby Thompson SFN
1989 AL OF Ruben Sierra TEX OF Jose Canseco OAK
NL P Rick Sutcliffe CHN P Mike Scott HOU
NL OF Eric Davis CIN OF Darryl Strawberry NYN
NL 3B Howard Johnson NYN 3B Mike Schmidt PHI
1990 AL IF Brook Jacoby CLE OF Ellis Burks BOS
NL C Mike Scioscia LAN C Benito Santiago SDN
1991 AL 1B Rafael Palmeiro TEX 1B Mark McGwire OAK
NL OF Ivan Calderon MON OF Darryl Strawberry LAN
NL P Mike Morgan LAN P Ramon Martinez LAN
1992 AL OF Joe Carter TOR OF Jose Canseco OAK
1993 NL OF Marquis Grissom MON OF Andy Van Slyke PIT
1994 NL SS Wil Cordero MON SS Barry Larkin CIN
NL P Rod Beck SFN P Jose Rijo CIN
NL OF Marquis Grissom MON OF Lenny Dykstra PHI
1995 AL 1B Tino Martinez SEA 1B Mark McGwire OAK
AL OF Kenny Lofton CLE OF Ken Griffey SEA
NL P John Smiley CIN P Greg Maddux ATL
NL SS Barry Larkin CIN SS Ozzie Smith SLN
NL 3B Vinny Castilla COL 3B Matt Williams SFN
1996 AL OF Brady Anderson BAL OF Ken Griffey SEA
AL Unknown 1B Frank Thomas CHA
NL OF Henry Rodriguez MON OF Tony Gwynn SDN
NL 3B Ken Caminiti SDN 3B Matt Williams SFN
1997 AL 1B Jim Thome CLE 1B Frank Thomas CHA
AL OF Paul O’Neill NYA OF David Justice CLE
NL OF Steve Finley SDN OF Kenny Lofton ATL
NL SS Royce Clayton SLN SS Barry Larkin CIN
NL C Charles Johnson FLO C Todd Hundley NYN
1998 AL 1B Rafael Palmeiro BAL 1B Mo Vaughn BOS
AL OF Manny Ramirez CLE OF Bernie Williams NYA
NL 2B Bret Boone CIN OF Sammy Sosa CHN
1999 AL P Charles Nagy CLE P Mariano Rivera NYA
AL DH Harold Baines BAL DH Jose Canseco TBA
NL P Scott Williamson CIN P Robb Nen SFN
NL OF Jeromy Burnitz MIL OF Tony Gwynn SDN
2000 AL SS Mike Bordick BAL 3B Cal Ripken BAL
AL 3B Tony Batista TOR SS Alex Rodriguez SEA
AL OF Carl Everett BOS OF Manny Ramirez CLE
NL SS Edgar Renteria SLN 1B Mark McGwire SLN
NL C Joe Girardi CHN C Mike Piazza NYN
NL OF Jeffrey Hammonds COL OF Barry Bonds SFN
NL OF Steve Finley ARI OF Ken Griffey, Jr. CIN
NL P Danny Graves CIN P Greg Maddux
AL Unknown P Pedro Martinez BOS
2001 AL OF Mike Cameron SEA OF Greg Vaughn TBA
AL P Jeff Nelson SEA P Mariano Rivera NYA
NL OF Cliff Floyd FLO P Rick Reed NYN
2002 AL P Ugueth Urbina BOS P Pedro Martinez BOS
NL P Vicente Padilla PHI P Tom Glavine ATL
NL P Mike Remlinger ATL P Randy Johnson ARI
NL P Robb Nen SFN P Matt Morris SLN
2003 AL 1B Jason Giambi NYA 1B Mike Sweeney KCA
AL OF Magglio Ordonez CHA OF Manny Ramirez BOS
AL P Roger Clemens NYA P Barry Zito OAK
NL P Kerry Wood CHN P Shawn Chacon COL
NL P Dontrelle Willis FLO P Kevin Brown LAN
NL 2B Luis Castillo FLO 2B Marcus Giles ATL
2004 AL Unknown OF Carlos Beltran KCA *
NL C Paul Lo Duca LAN 1B Sean Casey CIN
AL P Javier Vazquez NYA P Tim Hudson OAK
AL P Jake Westbrook CLE P Curt Schilling BOS
NL OF Carlos Beltran HOU * OF Ken Griffey CIN
2005 NL P Billy Wagner PHI P Pedro Martinez NYN
NL SS Jimmy Rollins PHI SS Cesar Izturis LAN
AL P Matt Clement BOS P Roy Halladay TOR
2006 AL 2B Jose Lopez SEA 2B Robinson Cano NYA
AL OF Gary Mathews, Jr. TEX OF Alex Rios TOR
AL OF Magglio Ordonez DET OF Manny Ramirez BOS
NL P Roy Oswalt HOU P Pedro Martinez NYN
NL P Chris Capuano MIL P Tom Glavine NYN
AL P Francisco Liriano MIN P Jose Contreras CHA
NL SS David Eckstein SLN SS Jose Reyes NYN
2007 NL P Roy Oswalt HOU P John Smoltz ATL
NL P Brandon Webb ARI P Brian Fuentes COL
2008 AL Unknown DH David Ortiz
NL 3B David Wright NYN OF Alfonso Soriano CHN
NL P Carlos Marmol CHN P Kerry Wood CHN
2009 AL OF Nelson Cruz TEX OF Torii Hunter ANA
AL 1B Carlos Pena TBA 2B Dustin Pedroia BOS
AL 3B Chone Figgins ANA 3B Evan Longoria TBA
NL OF Jayson Werth PHI OF Carlos Beltran NYN
NL P Trevor Hoffman MIL P Jonathan Broxton LAN
NL P Zach Duke PIT P Matt Cain SFN
2010 AL 1B Paul Konerko CHA 1B Justin Morneau MIN
AL P Andy Pettitte NYA P Clay Buchholz BOS
AL C John Buck TOR C Victor Martinez BOS
AL 2B Ian Kinsler TEX 2B Dustin Pedroia BOS
AL P Jered Weaver ANA P Trevor Cahill OAK
AL P Andrew Bailey OAK P Jared Weaver ANA
AL P Justin Verlander DET P C.C. Sabathia NYA
AL P Rafael Soriano TBA P Mariano Rivera NYA
NL P Hong-Chih Kuo LAN OF Jason Heyward ATL
NL P Heath Bell SDN P Yovanni Gallardo MIL
NL 2B Brandon Phillips CIN 2B Chase Utley PHI
NL SS Jose Reyes NYN SS Tory Tulowitzki COL
NL SS Rafael Furcal LAN SS Jose Reyes NYN
2011 NL 3B Pablo Sandoval SFN SS Jose Reyes NYN
NL 3B Scott Rolen CIN 3B Chipper Jones ATL
NL C Miguel Montero ARI 3B Placido Polanco PHI
NL P Kevin Correia PIT P Cole Hamels PHI
NL P Craig Kimbrel ATL P Matt Cain SFN
NL OF Andre Ethier LAN OF Shane Victorino PHI
NL OF Andrew McCutcheon PIT OF Ryan Braun MIL
AL P David Robertson NYA P David Price TBA
AL P CC Sabathia NYA P James Shields TBA
AL P Alexi Ogando TEX P CC Sabathia NYA
AL P Michael Pineda SEA P Justin Verlander DET
AL P Jon Lester BOS P Felix Hernandez SEA
AL P Ricky Romero TOR P Jon Lester BOS
AL SS Jhonny Peralta DET SS Derek Jeter NYA
AL 3B Kevin Youkilis BOS 3B Alex Rodriguez NYA
AL P Jordan W ALden ANA P Mariano Rivera NYA
2012 AL P Jake Peavy CHA P C.J. Wilson ANA
NL 3B Chipper Jones ATL OF Matt Kemp LAN
NL OF Matt Holliday SLN C Yadier Molina SLN
NL OF Michael Bourn ATL SS Ian Desmond WAS
NL OF Bryce Harper WAS OF Giancarlo Stanton MIA
2013 AL P Clay Buchholz BOS P Bartolo Colon OAK
AL P Bartolo Colon OAK P Grant Balfour OAK
AL P Jesse Crain CHA P Glenn Perkins MIN
AL P Justin Verlander DET P Chris Tillman BAL
AL P Yu Darvish TEX P Matt Moore TBA
AL P Hisashi Iwakuma SEA P Greg Holland KCA
NL P Jeff Locke PIT P Mark Melancon PIT
NL P Jordan Zimmermann WAS P Sergio Romo SFN
NL 1B Freddie Freeman ATL C Brian McCann ATL
2014 AL P Fernando Rodney SEA P David Price TBA
AL P Koji Uehara BOS P Masahiro Tanaka NYA
AL 2B Kyle Seager SEA C Matt Wieters BAL
AL SS Erick Aybar ANA OF Alex Gordon KCA
AL 2B Ian Kinsler DET DH Victor Martinez DET
NL P Tim Hudson SFN P Madison Bumgarner SFN
NL P Alfredo Simon CIN P Johnny Cueto CIN
NL P Huston Street SDN P Tyson Ross SDN
NL P Henderson Alvarez MIA P Jordan Zimmermann WAS
NL C Miguel Montero ARI C Yadier Molina SLN
NL P Jeff Samardzija CHN # None
2015 AL OF Brett Gardner NYA OF Alex Gordon KCA
AL 2B Brian Dozier MIN OF Jose Bautista TOR
AL P Hector Santiago ANA P Sonny Gray OAK
NL SS Troy Tulowitzki COL 2B Dee Gordon MIA
NL P Clayton Kershaw LAN P Max Scherzer WAS
NL OF Ryan Braun MIL OF Matt Holliday SLN
2016 NL SS Aledmys Diaz SLN 3B Matt Carpenter SLN
AL P Corey Kluber CLE P Marco Estrada TOR
NL P Bartolo Colon NYN P Madison Bumgarner SFN
NL P Max Scherzer WAS P Stephen Strasburg WAS
NL P Drew Pomeranz SDN P Noah Syndergaard NYN
NL OF Staring Marte PIT OF Yoenis Cespedes NYN
NL OF Jay Bruce CIN OF Dexter Fowler CHN
AL P Aaron Sanchez TOR P Craig Kimbrel BOS
AL P Jose Quintana CHA P Danny Salazar CLE
2017 AL P Chris Archer TBA P Corey Kluber CLE
AL 2B Robinson Cano SEA 2B Starlin Castro NYA
AL P Chris Devenski HOU P Dallas Keuchel HOU
AL P Brandon Kintzler MIN P Yu Darvish TEX
AL P Roberto Osuna TOR OF Mike Trout ANA
AL OF Justin Upton DET P Michael Fulmer DET
NL P Alex Wood LAN P Clayton Kershaw LAN
2018 AL C Yan Gomes CLE C Wilson Ramos TBA
AL 2B Jed Lowrie OAK 2B Gleyber Torres NYA
AL P Charlie Morton HOU P Aroldis Chapman NYA
AL P Blake Snell TBA P Corey Kluber CLE
NL C Yadier Molina SLN C Buster Posey SFN
NL P Zack Greinke ARI P Jon Lester CHN
NL P Jereny Jeffress MIL P Sean Doolittle WAS
NL P Ross Stripling LAN P Miles Mikolas SLN
* - In 2004, Carlos Beltran was voted by the players to the squad but was refused by the Commissioner since Beltran had been traded by Kansas City to Houston thus changing leagues. He was later named as a replacement on the NL squad.
Page Updated: 7/17/2018
All data contained at this site is copyright © 1996-2018 by Retrosheet. All Rights Reserved.