Retrosheet


East All Stars(E) (ASE) 4 West All Stars(W) (ASW) 3

Game played on Sunday, August 24, 1958 (D) at Comiskey Park I, Chicago IL
All-Star game

East All Stars(E)                   0 0 0  0 0 4  0 0 0   -   4  5  1
West All Stars(W)                   1 0 1  0 0 0  1 0 0   -   3  6  0

BATTING

East All Stars(E)                    AB   R   H  RBI    BB  SO    PO  A
Jesse Mitchell rf                     4   0   0    0     0         0   0
  Joe Henry rf                        1   0   0    0     0         0   0
Sherwood Brewer 2b                    3   0   1    0     1         1   0
Wiley Griggs 3b                       2   0   1    0     1         0   1
  Jesse Bass pr                       0   1   0    0     0         0   0
  Sweetwater Clifton 1b               1   0   0    0     0         0   0
Clarence King cf                      4   0   0    0     0         1   0
Birney Porter 1b                      1   0   0    0     1         0   0
  James Ivory ph, 3b                  2   1   1    0     0         1   0
Brown Jackson lf                      4   1   1    3     0         0   0
Eddie Alston ss                       1   0   0    0     1         0   0
  Bobby Sanders ss                    2   0   0    0     0         0   0
Art Hamilton c                        2   0   0    0     0         0   0
  Otha Bailey c                       1   1   0    0     1         1   0
Willie Harris p                       1   0   0    0     0         0   0
  Willie Smith p                      2   0   1    1     0         0   1
  John Winston p                      1   0   0    0     0         0   0
Totals                               32   4   5    4     5   5    27   2

FIELDING -
E: 1.  James Ivory. 

BATTING -
HR:  Brown Jackson. 
Team LOB:  6


West All Stars(W)                    AB   R   H  RBI    BB  SO    PO  A
Lonnie Harris cf                      4   1   0    0     1         1   0
Jim Robinson ss                       4   0   0    0     1         0   1
Willie White rf                       4   1   1    0     1         1   0
Rufus Gipson 2b                       3   0   1    1     0         0   2
  Ozzie Tidmore 2b                    1   1   1    1     0         0   0
Gideon Jarvis lf                      4   0   0    0     0         0   0
Ted Washington 3b                     2   0   0    0     2         0   0
  Sam Hill 3b                         0   0   0    0     0         0   0
James Banks 1b                        2   0   0    0     0         4   0
  John Self 1b                        1   0   1    0     0         0   0
Ike Barnes c                          2   0   1    0     0         0   0
  Ira McKnight c                      2   0   0    0     0         0   0
Charlie Pride p                       1   0   1    0     0         0   1
  Aubrey Grigsby p                    1   0   0    0     0         0   0
  Alton Strozier ph                   1   0   0    0     0   1     0   0
  Marion Cain p                       1   0   0    0     0         0   0
Totals                               33   3   6    2     5  10    27   4

FIELDING -
PB: 1.  Ira McKnight. 

BATTING -
3B:  Rufus Gipson. 
HR:  Ozzie Tidmore. 
SH:  John Self. 
Team LOB:  9

BASERUNNING -
SB:  Lonnie Harris, Willie White. 

PITCHING

East All Stars(E)                    IP      H   R   ER  BB  SO  HR  BFP
Willie Harris                        3       3   2    2   4   4   0  16
Willie Smith W                       3       2   0    0   1   4   0  12
John Winston SV                      3       1   1    1   0   2   1  11
Totals                               9       6   3    3   5  10   1  39

WP:  Willie Harris. 

West All Stars(W)                    IP      H   R   ER  BB  SO  HR  BFP
Charlie Pride                        3       2   0    0   2   1   0  13
Aubrey Grigsby L                     3       3   4    3   3   1   1  15
Marion Cain                          3       0   0    0   0   3   0  9
Totals                               9       5   4    3   5   5   1  37



Data shown are Retrosheet's best estimates.
Data may be estimated, incomplete, or missing.

Umpires: HP - Simon Lewis, 1B - T.H. Jefferson, 2B - Roy Young, 3B -  Angrum

Time of Game: 2:35   Attendance: 9527

Retrosheet Play-by-Play Account
Game of Sunday, 8/24/1958 -- East All Stars(E) at West All
Stars(W) (D)

Starting Lineups:

   East                          West                          
1. J.Mitchell          rf        L.Harris            cf        
2. S.Brewer            2b        J.Robinson          ss        
3. W.Griggs            3b        W.White             rf        
4. C.King              cf        R.Gipson            2b        
5. B.Porter            1b        G.Jarvis            lf        
6. B.Jackson           lf        T.Washington        3b        
7. E.Alston            ss        J.Banks             1b        
8. A.Hamilton          c         I.Barnes            c         
9. W.Harris            p         C.Pride             p         

ALL STARS(E) 1ST: Play-by-play deduced from newspaper game
stories and box sc $Gideon Jarvis and Rufus Gipson played for
West team in Chic but played for East team in NY; J.Mitchell
grounded out (C.Pride to J.Banks); S.Brewer singled; W.Griggs
singled [S.Brewer to second]; C.King lined to W.White [S.Brewer
to third]; B.Porter walked [W.Griggs to second]; B.Jackson
grounded out (R.Gipson to J.Banks); 0 R, 2 H, 0 E, 3 LOB.  All
Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 0.

ALL STARS(W) 1ST: L.Harris walked; L.Harris stole second;
J.Robinson walked; W.White forced J.Robinson (W.Griggs to
S.Brewer) [L.Harris to third, W.White to first]; W.Harris threw
a wild pitch [L.Harris scored, W.White to second]; R.Gipson out
on unknown play; G.Jarvis out on unknown play; 1 R, 0 H, 0 E, 1
LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 1.

ALL STARS(E) 2ND: E.Alston out on unknown play; A.Hamilton out
on unknown play; W.Harris out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0
LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 1.

ALL STARS(W) 2ND: T.Washington out on unknown play; J.Banks out
on unknown play; I.Barnes singled; C.Pride singled [I.Barnes to
second]; L.Harris out on unknown play; 0 R, 2 H, 0 E, 2 LOB. 
All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 1.

ALL STARS(E) 3RD: J.Mitchell out on unknown play; S.Brewer
walked; W.Griggs grounded out (R.Gipson to J.Banks) [S.Brewer to
second]; C.King grounded out (J.Robinson to J.Banks); 0 R, 0 H,
0 E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 1.

ALL STARS(W) 3RD: J.Robinson out on unknown play; W.White
walked; W.White stole second; R.Gipson tripled to left-center
[W.White scored]; G.Jarvis out on unknown play; T.Washington
walked; J.Banks out on unknown play; 1 R, 1 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  All
Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(E) 4TH: A.GRIGSBY REPLACED C.PRIDE (PITCHING);
B.Porter out on unknown play; B.Jackson out on unknown play;
E.Alston walked; A.Hamilton out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E,
1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(W) 4TH: B.SANDERS REPLACED E.ALSTON (PLAYING SS);
O.BAILEY REPLACED A.HAMILTON (PLAYING C); W.SMITH REPLACED
W.HARRIS (PITCHING); I.Barnes out on unknown play; A.Grigsby out
on unknown play; L.Harris out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0
LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(E) 5TH: W.Smith out on unknown play; J.Mitchell out
on unknown play; S.Brewer out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0
LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(W) 5TH: J.Robinson out on unknown play; W.White
singled; R.Gipson out on unknown play; G.Jarvis out on unknown
play; 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 0, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(E) 6TH: O.TIDMORE REPLACED R.GIPSON (PLAYING 2B);
J.SELF REPLACED J.BANKS (PLAYING 1B); I.MCKNIGHT REPLACED
I.BARNES (PLAYING C); W.Griggs walked; J.BASS RAN FOR W.GRIGGS;
C.King flied to L.Harris; J.IVORY BATTED FOR B.PORTER; J.Ivory
singled to right field [J.Bass to second]; B.Jackson homered to
leftfield [J.Bass scored, J.Ivory scored]; B.Sanders out on
unknown play; O.Bailey walked; I.McKnight allowed a passed ball
[O.Bailey to second]; W.Smith singled to right field [O.Bailey
scored (unearned)]; J.Mitchell out on unknown play; 4 R (3 ER),
3 H, 0 E, 1 LOB.  All Stars(E) 4, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(W) 6TH: J.HENRY REPLACED J.MITCHELL (PLAYING RF);
S.CLIFTON REPLACED J.BASS (PLAYING 1B); J.IVORY STAYED IN GAME
(PLAYING 3B); T.Washington walked; J.Self singled to shortstop
[T.Washington to second]; On a bunt I.McKnight forced
T.Washington (W.Smith to J.Ivory) [J.Self to second, I.McKnight
to first]; A.STROZIER BATTED FOR A.GRIGSBY; A.Strozier struck
out; L.Harris flied to C.King; 0 R, 1 H, 0 E, 2 LOB.  All
Stars(E) 4, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(E) 7TH: M.CAIN REPLACED A.STROZIER (PITCHING);
S.Brewer out on unknown play; S.Clifton out on unknown play;
C.King out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  All Stars(E)
4, All Stars(W) 2.

ALL STARS(W) 7TH: J.WINSTON REPLACED W.SMITH (PITCHING);
J.Robinson out on unknown play; W.White out on unknown play;
O.Tidmore homered to leftfield; G.Jarvis out on unknown play; 1
R, 1 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  All Stars(E) 4, All Stars(W) 3.

ALL STARS(E) 8TH: J.Ivory out on unknown play; B.Jackson out on
unknown play; B.Sanders out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0
LOB.  All Stars(E) 4, All Stars(W) 3.

ALL STARS(W) 8TH: T.Washington reached on an error by J.Ivory
[T.Washington to first]; J.Self out on a sacrifice bunt (unknown
fielder) [T.Washington to second]; I.McKnight out on unknown
play; M.Cain out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 1 E, 1 LOB.  All
Stars(E) 4, All Stars(W) 3.

ALL STARS(E) 9TH: S.HILL REPLACED T.WASHINGTON (PLAYING 3B);
O.Bailey out on unknown play; J.Winston out on unknown play;
J.Henry out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0 LOB.  All Stars(E)
4, All Stars(W) 3.

ALL STARS(W) 9TH: L.Harris out on unknown play; J.Robinson out
on unknown play; W.White out on unknown play; 0 R, 0 H, 0 E, 0
LOB.  All Stars(E) 4, All Stars(W) 3.

Final Totals      R   H   E  LOB
 All Stars(E)     4   5   1   6
 All Stars(W)     3   6   0   9


Back to Main Page for 1958 Negro League Season

Back to Main Page for Negro League Baseball

Data are shown for games which have been identified by Retrosheet. Missing data are not shown. Negro Leagues data should be viewed as incomplete.


Retrosheet website last updated December 3, 2024.
All data contained at this site is copyright 1996-2024 by Retrosheet. All Rights Reserved. Click here for information about the use of Retrosheet data

Send comments and suggestions to Tom Thress: tthress-ATsign-retrosheet.org.
Join the Retrosheet Discussion group here: RetroList
Retrosheet is an all-volunteer organization and a 501(c)(3) charitable organization. To volunteer, please e-mail Tom Thress. To make a donation, you can visit here: Donation Page