1886 New York Area: Brooklyn (AA), 3; Giants (NL), 1

Game 1, October 18, 1886
BRO  005 02   7  7  7
NYN  000 02   2  3  2
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Toole, LP: Keefe


Game 2, October 20, 1886
NYN  141 100   7  7  3
BRO  010 100   2  7  3
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Keefe, LP: Terry


Game 3, October 22, 1886
NYN  303 000   6  9 11
BRO  012 114   8  8  5
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Porter, LP: Welch


Game 4, October 23, 1886
BRO  003 010   0  2  2
NYN  000 000   4  6  0
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Terry, LP: Keefe

Note: Home team batted first in all four games