1883 New York: Metropolitan (AA), 2; Gothams (NL), 1; one tie

Game 1, October 15, 1883
NYN  000 020 000   2  6  3
NYA  000 000 21x   3  6  1
WP: Keefe, LP: Welch


Game 2, October 16, 1883
NYN  000 101 010   3  9  3
NYA  100 001 001   3  5  7
Game ended due to darkness


Game 3, October 17, 1883
NYN  100 001 30   5  9  9
NYA  330 030 01  10 11  4
Game ended due to darkness
WP: Keefe, LP: Welch


Game 4, October 18, 1883
NYN  633 020 100  15 15  3
NYA  000 210 000   3  9 10
WP: Ward, LP: Lynch