Retrosheet


Expanded Replay Usage

This list shows all instances of the use of the expanded replay system.
On January 16, 2014, the owners unanimously approved an expanded use of the replay
system to start in the 2014 season. This expansion covered the following play types:
*	Book rule double (often incorrectly called "ground rule double")
*	Fair/foul (outfield only)
*	Fan interference
*	Force play (except fielder's touching of second base on a double play)
*	Grounds rule
*	Hit by pitch
*	Home plate collision
*	Passing runners on the base path
*	Record keeping (such as ball/strike counts)
*	Runners touching a base (appeal play)
*	Stadium boundary calls (such as a fielder falling into the fan area to make a catch)
*	Tag play
*	Timing play (run scoring before the third out)
*	Trap play (outfield only)
The following play types were not covered in the new version of the system:
*	Balls and strikes
*	Checked swings
*	Fair/foul (infield only)
*	Interference
*	Obstruction
*	Trap play (infield only)

On February 20, 2015, Major League Baseball announced changes to the 2014 Expanded Replay system. The changes included new types of plays that are reviewable.
*	Runners leaving a base too soon
*	Runners properly touching a base on a tag up play

In 2016, a rule change was implemented about sliding into bases. The rules required that a runner:
*         makes contact with the ground before reaching the base
*         is able and attempts to make contact with the base
*         is able and attempts to remain on the base after the slide
*         slides within reach of the base without changing his path to make contact with the fielder

The penalty for violating this rule was an interference call, putting out the batter/runner at 1B. These plays are noted as Slide rule in the type column.

There were three outcomes defined:
*	Confirmed - clear and convincing evidence that the call on the field was correct
*	Stands - no clear and convincing evidence to confirm or overturn the call
*	Overturned - clear and convincing evidence that the call on the field was incorrect

Reviews in 2014
Reviews in 2015
Reviews in 2016
Reviews in 2017
Reviews in 2018


Reviews in 2019 Date Tm Opp In Initiator Umpire Type Ruling Time 03/21/2019 OAK SEA 12 Mgr Bob Melvin Mike Muchlinski Catch/no catch Confirmed 0:51 03/28/2019 SFN SDN 6 Mgr Bruce Bochy John Tumpane Tag Play Stands 1:41 03/28/2019 TBA HOU 7 Mgr Kevin Cash Sam Holbrook Hit by pitch Overturned 0:39 03/28/2019 MIN CLE 8 Mgr Rocco Baldelli Tom Hallion Hit by pitch Overturned 0:45 03/28/2019 KCA CHA 4 Mgr Ned Yost Gabe Morales Tag Play Overturned 2:29 03/28/2019 SEA BOS 2 Mgr Scott Servais Larry Vanover Tag Play Stands 1:57 03/28/2019 KCA CHA 8 Mgr Ned Yost Ron Kulpa Force Play Overturned 1:46 03/29/2019 TBA HOU 5 Mgr Kevin Cash Jim Wolf Force Play Overturned 0:45 03/29/2019 MIA COL 6 Mgr Don Mattingly Brian Knight Force Play Overturned 0:49 03/29/2019 MIL SLN 5 Mgr Craig Counsell Quinn Wolcott Tag Play Stands 1:51 03/29/2019 SEA BOS 5 Mgr Scott Servais Dan Bellino Force Play Stands 1:36 03/29/2019 SDN SFN 5 Mgr Andy Green Lance Barksdale Tag Play Stands 2:31 03/29/2019 LAN ARI 7 Mgr Dave Roberts Nic Lentz Tag Play Stands 2:36 03/29/2019 LAN ARI 11 Ump Brian Gorman Nic Lentz Tag Play Stands 3:40 03/30/2019 CLE MIN 4 Mgr Terry Francona Phil Cuzzi Hit by pitch Overturned 1:03 03/30/2019 ATL PHI 1 Mgr Brian Snitker Mike Winters Tag Play Overturned 1:20 03/30/2019 ATL PHI 6 Mgr Brian Snitker Rob Drake Force Play Overturned 1:18 03/30/2019 LAN ARI 3 Mgr Dave Roberts Tripp Gibson Force Play Confirmed 1:35 03/30/2019 BOS SEA 5 Mgr Alex Cora David Rackley Force Play Overturned 1:13 03/31/2019 PIT CIN 2 Mgr Clint Hurdle Andy Fletcher Force Play Stands 1:35 03/31/2019 CLE MIN 5 Mgr Terry Francona Phil Cuzzi Tag Play Stands 1:18 03/31/2019 KCA CHA 9 Mgr Ned Yost Gabe Morales Force Play Overturned 0:40 03/31/2019 PHI ATL 2 Mgr Gabe Kapler Rob Drake Hit by pitch Stands 1:27 03/31/2019 BAL NYA 9 Mgr Brandon Hyde DJ Reyburn Force Play Confirmed 1:14 04/01/2019 PIT SLN 4 Mgr Clint Hurdle Vic Carapazza Tag Play Overturned 2:00 04/01/2019 BAL TOR 4 Mgr Brandon Hyde Jansen Visconti Tag Play Stands 1:47 04/01/2019 HOU TEX 3 Mgr A.J. Hinch Jerry Meals Force Play Overturned 0:37 04/01/2019 MIA NYN 9 Mgr Don Mattingly Sam Holbrook Hit by pitch Stands 1:40 04/01/2019 COL TBA 8 Mgr Bud Black Eric Cooper Tag Play Overturned 1:15 04/01/2019 BOS OAK 2 Mgr Alex Cora Kerwin Danley Tag Play Stands 2:04 04/02/2019 TBA COL 1 Mgr Kevin Cash Will Little Force Play Overturned 2:13 04/02/2019 WAS PHI 3 Mgr Dave Martinez Chad Fairchild Force Play Confirmed 1:15 04/02/2019 MIA NYN 5 Mgr Don Mattingly Manny Gonzalez Tag Play Stands 1:03 04/02/2019 NYA DET 8 Mgr Aaron Boone Jeremie Rehak Force Play Overturned 0:51 04/02/2019 NYN MIA 7 Mgr Mickey Callaway Dan Iassogna Hit by pitch Overturned 1:10 04/02/2019 ARI SDN 2 Mgr Torey Lovullo Chris Guccione Force Play Overturned 0:39 04/02/2019 PHI WAS 8 Mgr Gabe Kapler Paul Emmel Hit by pitch Overturned 0:57 04/02/2019 WAS PHI 8 Ump Paul Emmel Paul Emmel Record Keeping Record Keepi0:57 04/02/2019 KCA MIN 9 Mgr Ned Yost Brian O'Nora Tag Play Stands 1:54 04/02/2019 TEX HOU 7 Mgr Chris Woodward Ron Kulpa Force Play Overturned 1:22 04/02/2019 BOS OAK 9 Mgr Alex Cora Greg Gibson Tag Play Stands 1:50 04/03/2019 TBA COL 4 Mgr Kevin Cash Andy Fletcher Tag Play Overturned 0:47 04/03/2019 PHI WAS 5 Mgr Gabe Kapler Paul Emmel Tag Play Overturned 1:41 04/03/2019 COL TBA 7 Mgr Bud Black Eric Cooper Force Play Overturned 0:58 04/03/2019 WAS PHI 8 Mgr Dave Martinez Bruce Dreckman Tag Play Confirmed 1:40 04/03/2019 TEX HOU 3 Mgr Chris Woodward Gabe Morales Tag Play Overturned 1:46 04/03/2019 SLN PIT 9 Mgr Mike Shildt Vic Carapazza Tag Play Stands 1:13 04/03/2019 SFN LAN 3 Mgr Bruce Bochy Larry Vanover Tag Play Confirmed 1:27 04/03/2019 BOS OAK 8 Mgr Alex Cora Nic Lentz Force Play Overturned 0:58 04/04/2019 OAK BOS 1 Mgr Bob Melvin Greg Gibson Force Play Stands 1:39 04/04/2019 BOS OAK 9 Mgr Alex Cora Tripp Gibson Tag Play Stands 1:23 04/04/2019 ATL CHN 4 Mgr Brian Snitker Adrian Johnson HP collision Confirmed 0:55 04/04/2019 ATL CHN 4 Mgr Brian Snitker Adrian Johnson Tag Play Confirmed 0:55 04/04/2019 CIN PIT 8 Mgr David Bell James Hoye Force Play Confirmed 1:06 04/04/2019 TEX ANA 1 Ump Larry Vanover Larry Vanover Home run Overturned 2:17 04/05/2019 TBA SFN 6 Mgr Kevin Cash Greg Gibson Force Play Overturned 0:33 04/05/2019 SLN SDN 6 Ump Mark Wegner Mark Wegner Rules Check Rules Check 0:27 04/05/2019 TBA SFN 9 Mgr Kevin Cash Tripp Gibson Slide Rule Confirmed 0:20 04/05/2019 TBA SFN 9 Mgr Kevin Cash Greg Gibson Force Play Confirmed 0:20 04/05/2019 CIN PIT 8 Mgr David Bell Mark Ripperger Force Play Stands 1:27 04/05/2019 TOR CLE 8 Mgr Charlie Montoyo Jim Wolf Tag Play Stands 2:23 04/05/2019 CIN PIT 9 Ump Jeff Kellogg Mark Ripperger Force Play Stands 1:16 04/05/2019 TEX ANA 3 Mgr Chris Woodward Dan Bellino Tag Play Overturned 2:01 04/05/2019 HOU OAK 9 Mgr A.J. Hinch Quinn Wolcott Hit by pitch Overturned 3:46 04/05/2019 ANA TEX 8 Mgr Brad Ausmus Alfonso Marquez Force Play Overturned 1:17 04/06/2019 CIN PIT 2 Mgr David Bell Mark Ripperger Tag Play Overturned 1:10 04/06/2019 PIT CIN 3 Mgr Clint Hurdle James Hoye Tag Play Overturned 1:09 04/06/2019 CIN PIT 8 Ump Jeff Kellogg Brian O'Nora Home run Confirmed 0:45 04/06/2019 CIN PIT 9 Mgr David Bell Jeff Kellogg Tag Play Overturned 1:40 04/06/2019 SFN TBA 5 Mgr Bruce Bochy Greg Gibson Tag Play Confirmed 0:57 04/06/2019 ANA TEX 4 Mgr Brad Ausmus Dan Bellino Force Play Overturned 1:00 04/06/2019 TOR CLE 6 Mgr Charlie Montoyo Jim Wolf Force Play Overturned 1:34 04/06/2019 BOS ARI 2 Mgr Alex Cora Ron Kulpa Tag Play Overturned 1:34 04/06/2019 BAL NYA 8 Mgr Brandon Hyde Angel Hernandez Force Play Overturned 1:12 04/07/2019 SDN SLN 3 Mgr Andy Green Stu Scheurwater Tag Play Overturned 0:56 04/07/2019 CHA SEA 3 Ump Paul Emmel Chad Fairchild Home run Confirmed 1:16 04/07/2019 MIL CHN 5 Mgr Craig Counsell Hunter Wendelstedt Force Play Overturned 0:42 04/07/2019 TBA SFN 1 Ump Kerwin Danley Kerwin Danley Home run Overturned 0:52 04/07/2019 TBA SFN 1 Mgr Kevin Cash Nic Lentz Tag Play Overturned 0:43 04/07/2019 OAK HOU 8 Ump Gary Cederstrom Quinn Wolcott Home run Confirmed 0:34 04/07/2019 OAK HOU 8 Mgr Bob Melvin Gary Cederstrom Tag Play Confirmed 0:31 04/07/2019 SEA CHA 7 Mgr Scott Servais Bruce Dreckman Force Play Overturned 0:52 04/07/2019 TEX ANA 8 Mgr Chris Woodward Alfonso Marquez Catch/no catch Overturned 1:55 04/08/2019 CHA TBA 8 Mgr Rick Renteria Vic Carapazza Tag Play Stands 1:07 04/08/2019 ANA MIL 3 Mgr Brad Ausmus Phil Cuzzi Tag Play Stands 1:58 04/08/2019 SDN SFN 7 Mgr Andy Green Gerry Davis Tag Play Stands 1:42 04/09/2019 TOR BOS 4 Mgr Charlie Montoyo Bill Welke Tag Play Overturned 1:51 (3) 04/09/2019 CIN MIA 4 Ump Kerwin Danley Scott Barry Home run Confirmed 0:29 04/09/2019 LAN SLN 1 Mgr Dave Roberts Jansen Visconti Boundary Call Overturned 1:37 04/09/2019 COL ATL 3 Mgr Bud Black Gabe Morales Force Play Overturned 1:17 04/09/2019 ATL COL 4 Mgr Brian Snitker Ron Kulpa Tag Play Overturned 3:05 04/09/2019 KCA SEA 7 Mgr Ned Yost Gary Cederstrom Tag Play Confirmed 1:04 04/09/2019 WAS PHI 10 Ump Mark Wegner Stu Scheurwater Home run Stands 1:01 04/09/2019 ATL COL 8 Mgr Brian Snitker Ron Kulpa Tag Play Stands 1:10 04/09/2019 ANA MIL 8 Mgr Brad Ausmus Adam Hamari Tag Play Overturned 1:31 04/10/2019 SDN SFN 5 Mgr Andy Green Gerry Davis Tag Play Overturned 0:50 04/10/2019 SDN SFN 8 Mgr Andy Green Jeremie Rehak Tag Play Stands 1:20 04/10/2019 HOU NYA 1 Ump Larry Vanover Larry Vanover Home run Overturned 3:09 04/10/2019 MIN NYN 8 Mgr Rocco Baldelli Rob Drake Force Play Stands 2:01 04/10/2019 ARI TEX 7 Mgr Torey Lovullo Paul Nauert Tag Play Confirmed 1:36 04/10/2019 TEX ARI 9 Mgr Chris Woodward Fieldin Culbreth HP collision Confirmed 0:26 04/10/2019 TEX ARI 9 Mgr Chris Woodward Fieldin Culbreth Tag Play Overturned 0:26 04/11/2019 LAN SLN 5 Mgr Dave Roberts Bill Miller Hit by pitch Stands 1:29 04/11/2019 ARI SDN 7 Mgr Torey Lovullo Mike Muchlinski Force Play Confirmed 0:50 04/12/2019 TBA TOR 5 Mgr Kevin Cash Ramon De Jesus Tag Play Overturned 0:32 04/12/2019 TBA TOR 7 Mgr Kevin Cash Ramon De Jesus Force Play Confirmed 0:57 04/12/2019 TBA TOR 7 Mgr Kevin Cash Gary Cederstrom Force Play Stands 0:57 04/12/2019 ATL NYN 7 Mgr Brian Snitker Alfonso Marquez Force Play Overturned 2:30 04/12/2019 WAS PIT 10 Mgr Dave Martinez Nic Lentz Force Play Confirmed 0:53 04/12/2019 HOU SEA 6 Mgr A.J. Hinch Phil Cuzzi Force Play Overturned 0:57 04/12/2019 LAN MIL 8 Mgr Dave Roberts Jeremie Rehak Force Play Overturned 0:38 04/12/2019 COL SFN 18 Mgr Bud Black CB Bucknor Force Play Confirmed 0:46 04/13/2019 BOS BAL 5 Mgr Alex Cora Jim Reynolds Hit by pitch Overturned 1:41 04/13/2019 TOR TBA 4 Mgr Charlie Montoyo Marvin Hudson Force Play Confirmed 0:46 04/13/2019 TOR TBA 4 Mgr Charlie Montoyo Ramon De Jesus Force Play Overturned 0:46 04/13/2019 TBA TOR 7 Mgr Kevin Cash Gary Cederstrom HP collision Confirmed 0:59 04/13/2019 TBA TOR 7 Mgr Kevin Cash Gary Cederstrom Tag Play Stands 0:59 04/13/2019 SDN ARI 1 Mgr Andy Green Nick Mahrley Tag Play Overturned 2:08 04/13/2019 NYN ATL 4 Mgr Mickey Callaway Dan Bellino Tag Play Stands 1:26 04/13/2019 SDN ARI 9 Mgr Andy Green Nick Mahrley Tag Play Confirmed 1:02 04/14/2019 TBA TOR 1 Mgr Kevin Cash Ramon De Jesus Hit by pitch Stands 1:19 04/14/2019 DET MIN 4 Mgr Ron Gardenhire Chris Guccione Force Play Overturned 0:58 04/14/2019 TOR TBA 8 Mgr Charlie Montoyo Gary Cederstrom Tag Play Confirmed 0:50 04/14/2019 HOU SEA 9 Mgr A.J. Hinch Phil Cuzzi Force Play Overturned 0:39 (1) - MLB later acknowledged that the call should have been overturned. (2) - MLB later acknowledged that an incorrect call was made on a pitch. (3) - This call resulted in an ejection. (4) - Game-ending play (5) - Game later rained out

See Replayed Homer Calls for additional information about and descriptions of the home run reviews.
Page Updated: 4/18/2019
All data contained at this site is copyright 1996-2019